In the Break Room after Amy announces no Cloud 9 stores will have anyone in a bunny costume, Glenn asks who'd like to come to his church's Passion play. Singling out Cheyenne and Garrett, they make excuses until Sandra volunteers to go. Glenn mentions that the audience will be so large, he wouldn't notice if anyone was there so everyone says they'll go. In the store, Glenn has difficulty while practising his line with Cheyenne and Jonah for his small part in the play. He receives a call that he's now required to play Judas and gets frantic. In the Surveillance Office, Dina sees someone in a bunny costume on the monitor and yells for Amy. When Amy arrives, the bunny is gone from the monitor and switching feeds, Amy is surprised that the Break Room has a hidden camera in it.
Questioning the legality of spying on the staff, she stops when she sees Mateo mimicking her. Learning there's an audio feed, she gives in and lets Dina turn it on. She listens to Carol and Mateo make fun of her. Glenn reads the script for his new part and doubts he can play the bad guy. Cheyenne and Jonah get him to tap into something bad he did during his childhood. Dina sees the bunny in the store but loses it during a chase. Asking Sandra if she saw the bunny, Sandra is ignorant and doesn't think the bunny is a big deal. Dina believes the person in the costume could be a threat and insists Sandra call her on the walkie if she sees it. Talking to Mateo, Amy stops doing an action she heard Mateo critisize and he lies that he loves it.
I don't say that!
Amy speaks to Jonah about Mateo's lie, but he's more concerned that the Break Room camera has replaced a smoke detector. He isn't successful getting her to accept that staff always complain about the boss. She asks for details of what else the staff have said about her resulting in Jonah back-tracking. Glenn tries role-playing his part with Garrett who uses it as an opportunity to make fun of him. In the Surveillance office, Amy and Jonah listen to the staff make fun of her while Amy takes notes on what she should change about herself. Saying she's going to drive herself nuts, Jonah stops and listens to Garrett compliment his shirt. He's pleasantly surprised as Garrett never says nice things about him. Dina makes a P.A. announcement that the bunny is dangerous and should be avoided.
Who is Judas?
While making Easter baskets, Jonah tries to get Garrett to compliment his shirt to his face but Garrett is ambivalent. A girl eats a large chocolate display bunny. (♫ Len - Steal My Sunshine ♫) Amy approaches a group of staff and acts in a manner to address all their criticisms. Confused about her odd behaviour, Sayid won't stop replying to Amy's "thank yous." Glenn practises various bad guy routines in a mirror. A boy sits on top of an end cap of toys and throws one down. (♫ Everclear - Father of Mine ♫) In the Break Room, the staff discuss Amy's behaviour while Jonah nervously looks at the smoke detector and unsuccessfully tries to change the subject.
Are you sick?
Sayid realizes Jonah isn't comfortable with them making fun of Amy until Cheyenne says that Jonah made fun of her the previous week. The staff mock what Jonah said until he swears at them and Mateo catches Jonah looking at the smoke detector. Once Jonah leaves the Break Room, Cheyenne tells the staff she drugged Amy's coffee. Amy runs in screaming, revealing that she's been spying on them. Cheyenne says she didn't drug her coffee and Amy is caught. Jonah pays Garrett several compliments, hoping to get one in return, but is disappointed. Dina continues to look for the bunny on the surveillance monitors. In the Warehouse, the bunny surprises Sandra from behind and takes the costume head off to reveal Jerry. Dressed up so he can spend the day with Sandra without Carol knowing about it, Sandra leads him to the Photo Lab to have sex.
My heart is beating so fast!
In the Break Room, the staff scold Amy while Glenn takes down the camera. Cheyenne wonders where else they're being spied on in the store leading Carol to worry that she's being watched when she masturbates in the store bathroom. Jonah tells the staff to not talk about people behind their backs and Sayid wonders who says good things about people when they aren't present. Mateo opines that everyone complains about the boss which Glenn worries happened when he was manager. On the monitors, Dina sees the bunny in the store behind Sandra. Calling her on the walkie, Sandra pretends she doesn't see it. Later, Dina worries that she's going crazy as it seems she's the only one who has seen the bunny. Seeking comfort from Sandra, she doesn't provide it and says Dina might be losing it.
It's a grey area.
Sandra leaves and Dina sees the bunny and closes her eyes. A customer throws a cup in a glass cage containing a bunny. (♫ Sara Bareilles - Love Song ♫) Jonah interrupts Garrett helping two customers and yells at him for not paying him a compliment to his face. After shouting several nice things about Garrett, he leaves in a huff. Garrett tells the customers that Jonah is his best friend. In the store, Amy approaches a group of staff and apologizes for spying on them. Making a hand gesture which the staff had made fun of, Cheyenne snickers and sends Mateo a text. He snorts at the text, leading Amy to ask about it. Lying that the text was from his mother, Amy demands to see it so Mateo throws his phone on the floor, smashing it.
You won't say nice things to my face!
Amy's name tag: Amy wears a different name tag in every episode. For this one it's "Bea."
Crazy Customers and music: For all customer interludes and music see Easter (music).
Amy and Jonah get combative to keep their new relationship hidden from their co-workers. Meanwhile, Glenn spirals when he learns Kelly wants to transfer to a new store, and Cheyenne struggles to organize a Cloud 9 carpool.
When an employee costume competition is announced, Amy and Mateo aren't afraid to play dirty to win first prize, a paid day off. Meanwhile, Glenn is preoccupied by Cloud 9's new automatic cart collector, and Garrett is tormented by an annoying Halloween novelty song.
Amy and Dina are both in labor! But while Glenn's manager status gets Dina the royal treatment at a fancy hospital, Amy and Jonah have a far different experience at a cheaper clinic. At the store, Garrett struggles to express his best wishes for the new parents.
Amy faces a nightmare day at work when she learns she doesn't have maternity leave, made worse by Cheyenne and Mateo campaign to change her baby's name. Meanwhile, Jonah and Garrett take on hiring the new seasonal help.
When a new Cloud 9 initiative forces employees to be friendlier to their customers, Amy ends up getting to know Jonah's parents, and learns he hasn't been completely truthful with them. The new policy also inspires Garrett and Dina to find out who can hold a smile longer.
Jonah and Amy take Glenn's tickets to a managers' conference in Chicago so they can enjoy a free night on the town, but their plan hits a few bumps. At the store, Cheyenne helps Mateo damage control after his undocumented status is leaked, and Dina and Garrett struggle at gift-wrapping.
Amy and Cheyenne attend Cloud 9 Academy to advance their careers. Dina and Garrett get roped into babysitting Glenn's daughter while he childproofs his office, and Jonah and Mateo become political activists.
Corporate introduces a friendly step-tracking challenge between Cloud 9 branches, and Amy, Jonah, and Dina create a fake rivalry to inspire Store #1217's laziest employees. But healthy competition gets increasingly chaotic when the fake rivalry becomes real.
Jonah and Amy's first Valentine's Day together gets derailed when Dina brings her birds to work, which also causes trouble for Garrett. Meanwhile, Cheyenne offers to give Marcus a sentimental tattoo, and Glenn makes videos for his daughter to watch while he's at work.
Amy jumps at an amazing career opportunity, only to run up against an exec with a major grudge against her. Jonah and Mateo help Glenn with a financial problem, while Garrett and Cheyenne struggle to spend a day without cell phones.
Amy finds herself at odds with her coworkers when some salary numbers get leaked, while Dina worries that Jonah is coming between her and Amy. Mateo tries to give himself a promotion, and Garrett attempts to sabotage Glenn's positive attitude.
Suspicious that people are making fun of her, Amy and Jonah spy on Cloud 9 employees through the security system, while Dina tries to track down an unsanctioned Easter Bunny in the store. Glenn preps for his church's Passion play.
Despite Dina's protests, Amy lets Glenn's pastor host an Earth Day booth at the store, but things quickly unravel when Glenn won't recognize Amy's authority. Jonah spearheads Cloud 9's green initiative, but is met with apathy from his coworkers.
Dina agrees to play the bad guy when corporate forces Amy to cut everyone's hours. Meanwhile, Jonah and the other employees play an elaborate game of laser tag with the store's new scanners, and Mateo makes a startling discovery about Marcus.
When a photo of a mess at store 1217 goes viral, Amy and Jonah try to use it to their advantage, while Dina starts hunting for the anonymous tweeter. And with money tight now that their hours have been cut back, Mateo, Cheyenne, Garrett, and Glenn sell their personal items in the store.
Amy and Dina visit Cloud 9 corporate to fix problems caused by Sandra's misguided activism, while Jonah tries to sabotage an employee meeting and Garrett tries to prove to his co-workers that he's a good person.
Amy and Jonah find themselves on opposing sides as corporate tries to win over employees by showering them with treats. But when the company's tactics grow more extreme, everyone must band together to save one of their own.